Toe-Up Drills For The Takeaway

Fri, 12/30/2011 - 15:33 -- Don Trahan

Today's daily is an answer to an excellent question posed by Lex van Weezendonk, a Surgite who lives just south of Brussels, Belgium.

"I still have a problem understanding the initial part of the takeaway. I do understand that the triangle should stay intact..but do I turn sideways (little turn with hip, keeping knees flexed with outward pressure) keeping my left hand palm facing forward while turning and making sure the clubhead moves first..or does the left hand palm roll under slightly, which tends to close the clubhead somewhat..I have watched your- and DJ's swing a zillion times and am still not sure what I am seeing. Hope I am expressing myself clear enough. Your answer is much appreciated."

As Lex notes, watching the detail of this portion of the swing can be difficult so I advise everyone to watch this tip in full screen mode. To do this, just click on the button with four outward-pointing arrows that is located in the lower right hand portion of the video player control bar.

Lex's question about the takeaway is an important one. If not properly executed, it will be difficult to get the club to a truly vertical position. We want the square of our body to set the triangle of our arms in motion with the thought of the toe of the club moving first. This small move is essential to being able to get the club positioned so that you can lift it without having to flip the club head into the Sacred Burial Ground at the top of the backswing. When you execute a good take away with the motion described above, you'll note that the back of your forward hand, which faces the target at address, will rotate slightly so that when you are in the Catcher's Mitt it will be facing away from you, as viewed from a face-on position. This is a pretty subtle movement but a really important one nonetheless.

Watch the video for a demonstration of three drills I use to teach this movement. If you can master the Shaking Hands Drill, The Clipboard Drill, and The Serving Champagne Drill you will be executing perfect takeaways that follow Secret #2: Palms Perpendicular. (For those of you who are wondering about "The Secrets", there are actually five of them and they are fully covered in the PPGS Swing Series instructional videos and in my 108-page illustrated Foundations Manual. Both are on sale through New Year's Day at 50% off their normal price.)

Keep it vertical!

The Surge

If you can't view the YouTube video above try CLICKING HERE. You must allow popups from this site for the link to work.

Blog Tags: 

Comments

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Maintaining our swing and keeping it vertical takes repeated vigilance.
I go between letting it go and being less mechanical to re examination and repair. Find the balance we must. I have still averaged scores in the mid 80's but am enjoying it as much or more than ever because of a deeper sense of mellowness and appreciation for my health and blessings to be able to play and really enjoy each day. Still, I have a fire in my belly to get better and break 80 again if not frequently. More convinced than ever it's the chips and putts that will get me there. That'll be my focus for 2012.
PMG and become a SGW (short game wizard) 
 

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

All of us have a place we are going to get "stuck".
(If you are going to be stuck the 70s is a good place for it).;-)
It will be from limited play and practice time and also the point that whatever talent we have maxes out.

I've pretty much been in that spot for a while. I can hit the ball better and more consistently but don't do other things as well because I don't play enough so they sort of cancel each other out.
I'm at the age where I can expect to start really losing distance and that's going to be hard to make up in other areas without access to a range and very limited play so there's a good chance I've already played my best golf. If that's the case I'm fine with it. I only want to play as well as I can with what I've got and the time I have to do it.
The shame is when somebody is stuck at a score way above what they could easily do if they only understood a point or two about their swing.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Thanks for coming back on and clarifying what you are doing.
I could see when I tried it that it would be very hard to get into the SBG up the forward tree while doing that and if that feeling carries over to the real swing it would be a benefit.

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Ncorkrum,

Sorry, but it's like the Mafia, once you're in, there's no getting out. LOL

Actually just check near the bottom of your next email, and you'll find a spot that say's click here to unsubscribe.

Happy New Year.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Agree with your philosophy Jack. Practice and seeking to improve our ways on the range and at home and then simply do our best to enjoy ourselves on the course regardless. This attitude has lead to more good shots too because of not over reacting to a poor shot and being able to refocus and calmly play the next. The saying goes, "we don't play golf to relax, we relax to play golf." 
 

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

I (think) I know what you mean at the very start of the takeaway. More or less reinforcing that the right forearm doesn't get above the left, but the thought of keeping your right arm "tucked" can be very detrimental to this swing if you are talking about anything after the first few inches.
The right arm has to have the freedom to come away from the body in the back swing.

Don has done dailys on this that unfortunately are no longer available.

Things such as "being connected" and putting a glove under your arm pit are strictly rotational drills and not conducive to this swing and in fact very few of the bigger hitting rotational players that I'm seeing now keep the right elbow tucked.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Is it hard to change something when you're hitting "lasers"?

My son is trying to change his swing. He said he thought he would never get any better unless he did and I agree with him. The problem is that he is used to shooting under par most of the time and the changes he needs to make are so drastic that his game will most likely fall apart with everything he tries to do.
He is not a "rock skipper" and the swing he taught himself is the opposite of what he needs to do.
Speaking of "rock skippers".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...

P.S. All of that you wrote doesn't sound any different than what I could write almost every day.
(Except for the "darts" and "laser" parts). Ha ha!

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

I'm not certain, but I think he means that he keeps his left heel off the ground through the practice swing, which keeps the left hip from over-rotating. Not something you'd want to do in an actual swing, clearly.

OzDon's picture

Submitted by OzDon (not verified) on

Thanks Surge for your generous free advice.
I would also like to recommend Derek Hardy's Tissue Box drill which helped me a lot. It is currently listed as "On, on, on" but when try to play it a message says "removed by user.' Not sure what is the problem but if you want to re-list this drill I have a copy on my hard drive and could send it to you.
For me I try to focus on the forward wrist throughout my swing and not the club. (Making sure it is on the toe line) I like Derek's point that the club face will be pointing slightly downwards at the mitt because we are bent over. If I point it straight up at the mitt I almost always lay it off at vertical and have trouble bringing the face square at impact

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

There is no "Surgism" that says anything about bending the left arm in the lift up the tree.

As for "how many folks take the Surgisms too literally".
Probably way too many. Especially once we walk out on the golf course.

If we want to change our swings, for whatever reason, we must try to follow the rules for whatever we are trying to achieve in practice.

People that have a pressing reason for changing their swing, ie. back problems or other injuries or just a lack of any success with what they are doing, would be likely to take the approach of basically tearing down their old swing and starting from scratch.

Others are in no big hurry to change things and are content to add a tweak here or there one at a time in practice and having very few swing thoughts on the course. Some of those "tweaks" will fit in right away and produce great results right away. Others will not and we have to accept that when we look at a video from the course those will not be evident.

It's up to each of us to figure out which tweaks are crucial to our success and which are just something to work on but not as necessary for success.

An example of something that is critical to my success is a flat left wrist and as limited as possible wrist action.

An example of something not nearly as critical, but desirable enough to work on in practice, is having the shaft completely vertical at the end of the back swing.

No matter which approach to learning we choose to take there are two things IMO that are a must if we are attempting to make a vertical swing. Those are getting the entire shaft to the toe line and letting the club drop into the slot from the top. I have yet to see a good swing without both of those in place.

If I were to teach someone to swing a club those are the two things that we would do over and over without a ball until that swing path became ingrained (no matter how long it took). Then we could move on to other things.

Any old habit that doesn't include those two things is just too hard to break and the two go hand in hand. Go to any course on any day and you will see people flipping the hands clockwise and swinging at the ball from the top without dropping into the slot. Over and over again with no chance at any real success. Some of them learn to hit that way and think they are doing OK but they will always be stuck trying to break 80.

SimplyGolf's picture

Submitted by SimplyGolf (not verified) on

Steve-
Thanks for another great....takeaway. (no pun intended).

Your thoughts are well articulated and focused.
I've especially benefitted from your "in the slot"
comments. I never really gave that much consideration
prior.  It's now a crucial part of my swing.

Tide vs Tigers should be an epic battle. Sure many in the Nation will think of you during that game.

SG

Markus's picture

Submitted by Markus (not verified) on

Don, I have a question to the initial turn. I understand it is an approx 60-70° turn around the spine, hands stay perpendicular. Champagne drill. After that it is all arm lift. Correct? My question is, does that initial turn until the arm lift differ from a typical rotational swing (beside the different set up), or is it similar?

MikefromKy Go Bama. Go Irish's picture

Submitted by MikefromKy Go B... (not verified) on

T

I agree with you and Steve. When I get into trouble with this swing I take to slow / smooth of a back swing another words to slow of a tempo for me.

For me when I do this swing correctly I need to swing the club back into the
mitt and up the tree with what FEELS like a arm swing this gets me the shoulder turn of about were Don is.On the start of the FUS my bump FEELS like it starts when my hands FEEL like they are maybe hip high but in reality they are probably shoulder high.

When I get these Feels and not focusing on turn the ball goes long and straight.

When I revert back and focus on the body turning its not good.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Practicing the set up and alignment routine has helped me be able to no longer have to work on those during play. Getting the funamentals to a point of being natural is what practicing does for me. This improves my chances of taking it from the range to the course.  
 

Dstansbery's picture

Submitted by Dstansbery (not verified) on

Bob, sometimes when I'm having trouble executing toe up, I also have to think "tuck and lift". But as Steve said, you're only passing your elbow through that position. I find concentrating on thumbs up more helpful than toe up. I can feel thumbs up as a part of my arms, but have to peek to check toe up.

Dale

Boogm's picture

Submitted by Boogm (not verified) on

I was hitting some hitting some dandy shots, guess it was one of those video tells you something you don't know moments and I may be overwhelmed in the thinking that I was a lot closer to the Surge swing than I really am. You know what I mean. I remember the first time I used the Surge swing my only thoughts, keys or whatever we want to call them was "thumbs up" in the BUS and "down the line" in the FUS and had pretty good success. Today I went with none and was just swinging,pretty well, but the positions I have become accustomed to weren't there but the ball was going to my target way more than less. Maybe I just need to  clear my head and sleep on things,something like a Bama victory in the championship game. :)

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

I didn't even know if keeping the left heel off of the ground up the forward tree would even be possible with any weight transfer so I had to walk out on the porch and try it and it was better than I expected it to be, and it did keep the path up the forward tree more vertical.

I can't really see that it would be any advantage to use it in a practice swing if not intended for a real swing though, and with a real swing I think it would be easy to be off balance on any slight uneven slope, even for someone that didn't have the leg issues that I have.

Hard enough to keep my balance with the entire left foot on the ground in the finish.

But if he says it helps, and since I'm not exactly sure how he uses it, it's hard to say.........

MikefromKy Go Bama. Go Irish's picture

Submitted by MikefromKy Go B... (not verified) on

First off I have to say I am sorry.

But I am confused sort of I was under the impression that we started the back swing with a one piece takeaway meaning the hands, arms,shoulders,hips start the club back together. In the video the thought of the club head starts back first how do we make this happen a rolling of the forearms or setting of the right wrist I have to be missing something in this video are some were. I never have a problem getting to toe up I am just curios if I am turning to much at the beginning.

I am just wanting to make sure I am doing this correctly not trying to be argumentative . So don't holler at me. 

shortgamewizard's picture

Submitted by shortgamewizard (not verified) on

Steve hit on the really crucial point of hitting the slot in his post above. Look at the recent swings in V1 and identify the angle of the shaft as it hits the slot on the downswing. The bump should flatten the shaft angle from the top down into the slot angle. Too much or too little will create all sorts of pandemonium in the flight of the ball.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

I just hope they aren't thinking "boy I bet Steve is disappointed about this game".

Ha ha!

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Surge, thanks for covering the basics of the initial take away. It is so easy to get it wrong and over turn or under/over rotate hands. The best of your thoughts for me was the visual of your watch and back of glove emblem. That shake hands thumbs up of the back hand also ties in perfectly as it's all straight up from there. I will work on these among other drills because I still have the tendency to allow my hands to rotate back into the SBG. Steve and I talked about how that back (right) hand needs to control the lift in order to get it vertical from that 9 oclock position to the top.
PMG

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Roger, one of the key feelings of the one piece takeaway is that we lift with the hands, wrists and arms from the shoulder sockets. This helps us maintain the wrist angle established at address and avoid the wrist cock. Little turn and alot of lift. I'll leave this great artical that may help. A key though here in is that Surge has the "sense and  feeling" that the toe of the club moves first. See third paragraph.http://www.swingsurgeon.com/Home/BobS...

nick's picture

Submitted by nick on

Hello there, all you Surge Swing fans. I´d like to contribute a little tip that I have found very beneficial when it comes to making a correct follow threw. I always found the take away and back swing relatively easy to get right, but the follow through (with the high speed) often ended up to much laid off, which naturally had a varying degree of negative effect at the impact position. Then I started to lift my left heel in my practice swings, which forced me to keep the follow though sufficiently steep (up the tree) so I could maintain my balance and it has worked wonders. To use The Surge´s own words it helps me feel the swing correctly and then I simply swing that feel. For all I know this tip could have appeared on a daily video, that I have missed, and if that's the case just see this as a reminder.
All the best
IrishNick

Dragonhead's picture

Submitted by Dragonhead (not verified) on

Steve, Your comment is succinct and to the point. After carefully watching today's video, these simple drills will be getting a real run.Weather here is non stop rain at present. Just like the Emerald Isle, it is green because...... ; - ]  My wife is chipping occasionally now when we go out. Methinks she has the 'bug' hahaha. Measured her WTF yesterday and found her WTF is exactly the same as mine, hahaha. So she now has her own set of clubs etc.The Mizuno are just right for her. Next Chinese New Year around the 20th of Jan 2012 is appropriately, the Year of the Dragon! hahaha. Have a great Hogmonay and keep on PMG and explaining the way you interpret things. They help a lot. Good health, wealth and luck to you and Yours this New Year. NOW off to practice.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

I'm still waiting on the day when I look at a video and it looks just like I thought it would, and should. ;-)

Of course it also seems like I get pickier about what I want it to be all the time too!

Dave Everitt's picture

Submitted by Dave Everitt (not verified) on

Nick,

If I understand you correctly this is only something you do only during a practice swing.  It probably gives you the feel of preloading heavy right.  It duplicates the feeling of hitting a ball on an uphill lie.  Surge talks about this feeling of hitting from an uphill lie, when he describes hitting from a PLHR address.A previous blogger had a similar idea that he used when PLHR for the real swing.  He had good luck preloading his weight right before every shot, by momentarily raising his front heel a couple of inches , lowering it to the ground, and leaving his weight shifted right, before hitting the ball.It didn't work for me, but it's certainly worth a try. Don't pay too much attention to naysayers. Heh, whatever works!  Many of us are looking for new ideas.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Rodger,

Do me a favor.

Go to the kitchen. Get a glass of water. Hold it between your palms. Hand it to an imaginary person standing on the toe line beside you.

That's it!

Whatever you felt started the action will be what it is. Some people will feel like the action started with a slight turn of the hips. Some will feel like it was a slight turn of the shoulder. Some will feel like it was the hands and arms moving first. Some will feel like it was everything moving together.
All for exactly the same action.

The only thing that is important is to get the water to the person beside you without spilling it.

Everything after that is lift.

shortgamewizard's picture

Submitted by shortgamewizard (not verified) on

A couple of points to help your short game wizardry.

Develop a consistent stroke so you can hit on the line you want every time.

On chips and pitches try to leave a make able distance. Nothing better than having simple putts to save a shot.

Try to play the shots from the fairway or tee on the par 3s so you don't short side yourself. Easy chips and pitches go in more often.

CharlieY's picture

Submitted by CharlieY (not verified) on

T Medley,  the cause of the spinal infection this time was the one I had ten years ago.  Apparently, once you get one, it can come back, as a new infection, not a carry over from the old one.  The cause of the first one is the one that is in doubt.  Medical web pages say that if you bruise some tissue in your body, it becomes susceptible to bacteria so that if you just happen to have something like a bladder infection or a kidney infection (or some other large source of bacteria), the bacteria can find its way to the bruised tissue.  That's why football players who bruise a part of the foot have been known to come down with a bone infection.

Another realization about my lifting the hands instead of swinging the club in the BUS--it seems that the muscles in my arms became activated too much and prevented a repetition of a smooth BUS.  Of course, this is just conjecture based on swinging both ways,, a wider, smoother BUS versus lifting the handle too vertically once the catcher's mitt was reached.

Thanks for the post.

Jsmith's picture

Submitted by Jsmith (not verified) on

Don,  Best wishes for the New Year.

Great lesson today. It covered a point that I have wondered about.

To all Surgites--I just bought the Harvey Ward putting video. It is outstanding and well worth the price. I think Don's special goes  off this weekend. As an aside, I was lucky enough to have taken  some lessons from Harvey in San Francisco in the mid-70's (not putting). He was a really nice guy-patient and knowledgeable

Dmwheat4's picture

Submitted by Dmwheat4 (not verified) on

Oh Dear,,,,

Dmwheat4's picture

Submitted by Dmwheat4 (not verified) on

Thanks Surge, great tip!!  Got out today, little cool out 42 and some wind, the weather man was wrong!!!   Played ok, had allot of toe shots today, so, need to go back and OH, how I wish I could hit the ball good most of the time, but, it will take time, I guess??

Happy New Year!! 

marilyn

Lynn42's picture

Submitted by Lynn42 (not verified) on

Steve

I went back to the video I shot for Doc for my long distance driver.  Ugghh, scary stuff.  Just when you think you have a pretty good idea of what you're doing it opens your eyes bigtime.  I come much closer to verticle when I concentrate on pointing my right elbow upward at setup and just concentrate on "thumbs up".

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

I think he is talking about the left heel being off of the ground up the forward tree to keep the left leg flexed and keep the left hip from opening.
It definitely does both but since most people have a big problem with weight transfer and end up reverse tilting after impact it might make those people fall back even worse.
 Maybe Nick will come back on and clarify just what he is doing and what it is accomplishing, and whether it is just in the practice swing, and why in the real swing he wouldn't just go back to over rotating in the finish.

P.S. I saw an instructor hitting practice shots with both heels on a board to try to get the feeling of keeping both legs flexed at each side of the swing.

dgaines's picture

Submitted by dgaines on

Page 60 - 61 of the PPGS manual.
"I define a one-piece takeaway as one in which the clubhead’s movement is begun by the turning of your torso and your shoulders.Meanwhile, the club is merely held passively in your
hands. By this I mean that your hands and arms are put into motion by your upper body This motion of your torso and shoulders carries down to your hips, legs and feet."

I believe Don says that his rear hip starts the motion first and the clubhead moves a nano-second later.

Dstansbery's picture

Submitted by Dstansbery (not verified) on

You're right Steve, nothing about bending the left arm from Surge, and I'm not discounting any of his teachings at all.  I'm just saying that you have to keep everything in context of a golf swing action. I've probably struggled as much  or more than most to convert, and one of my problems is not just swinging, but trying to manage my swing, if that makes sense, introducing muscle tension where it doesn't belong.

CharlieY's picture

Submitted by CharlieY (not verified) on

Robert--I made a few rather understated posts because I didn't want to make too much of the health issue.  While it is/was rather serious, there are others on the blog who have gone through much more serious treatments without so much as a hint to us.

Back to golf--you can't imagine how much weight has been lifted from my mind, now that I feel that I'm back in control of my progress.  For a time, I thought I would never get it back.  I even began to consider that the eight weeks of daily IV antibiotics re-configured my brain (too much science fiction movies).  After all, they say that illegal drugs can change the mental structure of the brain, so why not antibiotics?  Glad I was wrong.  Oh, oh, but I did find out that I can now do crossword puzzles that I couldn't complete previously.

Harry Rogers's picture

Submitted by Harry Rogers (not verified) on

Don
Keep it up.  Tips are great.  My Pro has told me that as I swing to the top, my grip changes making the club hood at inpack and causing the ball to go left.  I cannot seem to change it.  Any ideas.  I'm using two gloves and hand still turns.
Harry Rogers
Eaton's Neck, LI, NY
Sunset Beach, NC

Cgates1's picture

Submitted by Cgates1 (not verified) on

This is one of the best I've seen---you must start the back swing correctly and this drill does just that--thanks

Duke Johns's picture

Submitted by Duke Johns (not verified) on

Great Post Surge. I really enjoy this swing. I'm a bulky guy (weight trainer) and although I'm flexible and can do a regular golf swing, it was always uncomfortable for me. Today's advice was spot on. This swing has really helped my consistency and accuracy.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

We could probably put all of our swing videos together and make either a horror movie or a comedy out of them. LOL
Yeah the inner part of the elbow up at address puts it in a more natural position to lift, almost like doing a curl with weights.

MikefromKy Go Bama. Go Irish's picture

Submitted by MikefromKy Go B... (not verified) on

It might make sense to have up in the BUS and plant it to start the FUS not sure if that would work.

MikefromKy Go Bama. Go Irish's picture

Submitted by MikefromKy Go B... (not verified) on

Steve I get that. That's a non issue I generally don't even think about it. It just happens on its own. I guess the words of the thought of the club head moving first kinda of threw me a little about 1:40ish in.

It just looks like that when Don gets into the mitt his shoulders have turned way less than mine I maybe reading to much into it. .

I need to pick up a tripod can't find the one we had so I can get some video and upload it maybe stop on the way to the range tomorrow then we will see if I am anywhere close.  

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Makes perfect sense to me Dale. The only way I can play my best golf is to leave the things I am working on at home.
Once I get to the course I just have to consider myself an athlete that knows how to play the game.
I don't remember standing in a batters box or lining up for a kick or going up for a jump shot and thinking about mechanics, and I don't consider golf any different.

That doesn't mean I don't work on mechanics in all of those sports including golf. It just means that you work on your swing off of the course and trust your swing on the course.

Any doubts about mechanics in competition are a killer.
(In any sport).

Pages