Best Shot of the Year!

Sat, 07/23/2011 - 13:00 -- Don Trahan

In this video Greg MacDonell, my chief Director of Golf Instruction, and I review some of the things we observed in last week's golf school at Orange County National in Orlando. This year we have spent a considerable amount of time talking about the importance of proper club length and, once again, we had several students who were playing with clubs that were too long for them. Fortunately, Bill Marshall, our Certified Club Fitter from nearby Lakeland, Florida was there to help. In one instance, he built a new 6-iron for one of our lady students that was a full two inches shorter than her store-bought club. The improvement in her shots once she had her new club were truly amazing.

We also had three guys, all recent converts from big rotational swings, that kept going deep into the Sacred Burial Ground. As a result, their hands were not in the correct position at the top of their swing and they kept slicing the ball badly. If you've been following the blog recently you'll know that my recent comments on how to properly make a vertical swing touched off a lively discussion among members of The Surge Nation. One thing I didn't touch on then, but do today, is the benefit you can get through using a swing plane training aid like the SwingTECH product we endorse. It is a fool-proof way of ensuring that you learn to feel what a proper swing feels like. It sure helped these guys to stop playing Banana Ball.

This was a great group of students who were there to really improve their games but they also had great senses of humor. They played a pretty good practical joke on me while another one made what has to be The Shot of the Year.

Keep it vertical!

The Surge

If you can't view the YouTube video above try CLICKING HERE. You must allow popups from this site for the link to work.

Blog Tags: 

Comments

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Dick, Thanks for keeping the blog informed. We are all hoping they can be recovered and re-posted with their respective dates and blogs. Please keep us informed on any progress. Thanks for your assistance, it is well appreciated.

As for a round in Columbus with you and Roger,  it sounds interesting if times and dates permit. I live in the Canton area which is about 2hrs north of Columbus. My SSGS Fitter 
http://deadsolidperfectgolfclu...
is in the Columbus area and would perhaps be interested as well. Tina, whom I recently met in Mansfield with my fitter is about an hour north of me in the Cleveland area. I seem to recall one other in the Ohio area, but the name is slipping away. 

If you are going to be in the Cincinnati area there is an SSGS certified fitter there as well.
Just in case you're in the market for one.
 http://www.conquestcustomgolf....

Larry7834's picture

Submitted by Larry7834 (not verified) on

What you said is true but as a measurement only one is measured from wrist to floor and the converted to actual club length for each club.

Roy Reed's picture

Submitted by Roy Reed (not verified) on

Dan:  Good info and I really appreciate it.  Sounds like it really depends on the particular course we are playing determines what wedges we use.  Thanks much, R2

Roy Reed's picture

Submitted by Roy Reed (not verified) on

Doc:  Thank you for explaining this to me in your e-mail the other day.  You've talked about it before but it just didn't sink into the old memory bank. lol.

 One question, a little off topic.  I am wondering if there is a "standard" bounce for sand wedges.  I have one that is 10*, and one that is 14*, and a 1-Iron SW that claims to be 6*.  I believe that most people use a 10* bounce, but was wondering if you could shed a little light on it for us.  Thanks much, R2

Robert Bgolfer2 Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Bgolfer2... (not verified) on

Hey Bob, just noticed your post. How you doing pal? Did you start golf school yet? I want to hear all about it. Let us know.

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Robert, I play in a mixed church league on Monday evenings. The old saying, enough to make a preacher cuss is so true. I have heard words come out of the mouths of people that would never be heard in any other situation. Just like me, they are always embarrassed and sorry after it slips past the lips. The more heart you put into it, the more aggravating it can be. PMG

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

That's not sand, it's hard pan, and needs to be played the same as any other hard pan lie you might encounter anywhere else on the course. Good clean ball contact first. In a bunker, you need a club with a sufficient loft to carry any high lips as primary and distance as secondary, since the distance won't matter, if you can't clear the lip. At least that's how I play hard pan in a bunker.

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

I was not at all scared off by the tirade. You should see me when I really get frustrated. :) I have done my best to learn curse words in as many languages as possible.

One aside thought about what I was working on during our round that came clearer in my brain since. Particularly with the driver, I was focusing on starting the turn with the shoulders while I focused the arms only on lifting and keeping the palms perpendicular. I should have focused on that with the irons, as well, as maybe I'd have thinned fewer. I found that it let me keep my arms clear of my chest better, without the tendency to want to push them out.

Tom H's picture

Submitted by Tom H on

Surge, would you consider relocating your MIKE or adjust the volume higher. At times I can barely hear you with my speakers set as high as possible.

Thanks in advance,
Tom H.

Roy Reed's picture

Submitted by Roy Reed (not verified) on

Steve:  Thanks for the reference to Doc's video.  It really helps to see what the "norm" is, and I realize now it just depends on playing conditions.  Sounds like you have a tough course there at Lil Mole.   Our courses here in Northern Utah have a wide variety of playing surfaces and conditions, and sometimes it is hard to decide what club to use.  By the way, thanks for posting your swing videos - they are interesting and it is fun to see how your swing improves as you work on getting all the little "details" worked out.  Keep hitting 'em straight!  R2  

Russty Kiwi's picture

Submitted by Russty Kiwi (not verified) on

Thanks Roy.    You are absolutly right and have swarn an oath to never buy another club over the internet unless its through a fitter. Hopefully Doc.      Cheers Russty

shortgamewizard's picture

Submitted by shortgamewizard (not verified) on

What I like the most is the shot has less spin than one with a lot of arm rotation. Out here in the desert the greens tend to firm up so a spinner is of much less use. Also slightly opening or closing the club face can influence the ball on slopes similar to how a cue ball's spin can move it where you want on the table.

Yesterday I played 9 to test out a different driver and had 10 putts for a 2 under 34. Up and down 5/5 with one chip in, 3/3 sandies. The 2 holes not one putted where long putts for a birdie and an eagle on the par fives.

The driver tested will go back to its resting place. Great launch angle, too little spin and the shaft a bit too soft.

Boogm's picture

Submitted by Boogm (not verified) on

Mike, congrats on gathering it all together after the slow start. I feel for you and not having a place to warm up before your round.Cumberland Lake does but it's hitting floaters into the lake and I just don't see how that can help to much.When I have time and isn't so blasted hot I slip up to Limestone Springs and warm up then come back down to CL to play my round.Continued success, my friend and will continue to look forward to your updates.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

It may not be sand but it's the only way I know to get a bunker shot off of something as hard as "concrete".

Amos's picture

Submitted by Amos (not verified) on

Steve Smith:

   YES -- that is the best solution == "stay out of those bunkers"
    Unfortunately, we have smallish greens and on average 3 bunkers per green.
    Why is it so difficult to hit a green and so easy to hit the bunkers beside it?   LOL

    Amos

Doc Griffin's picture

Submitted by Doc Griffin (not verified) on

Let me try this.  If I ask you to get in the ready position, what position are you getting in?  Are you in the driver stance position or the PW position?

Now, that's a bit of misleading question as in the proper address position your hands are basically in the same position as the lie angle gets more upright as the club gets shorter which keeps the hands centrally  located. 

The accepted measuring position is at attention with shoulder and head up and hands down by the side.  This gives the fitter a starting point with which to work in regards to length.  It's a guide not a given. 

I see your position as an assumption that the player knows what the proper address position is and I see it as the player gets in the position based on habit and what he's accustomed too.  In other words, a player that has clubs to long would by nature have an improper ready position as would a player with clubs too short.  The WTF chart is based off of years of experience and again is a guide to the starting point for a players proper length.

Robert Bgolfer2 Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Bgolfer2... (not verified) on

Hey Terry and Steve, Ya I do get a little intense. Robert is very polite and a calm soul. I just hope I didn't scare him off with my little tiraid (sp?). Over all I am pleased with my progress. That 7 on the last hole included my only 3 putt of the morning. That was a flash of my old self, by the green in two on a par 5 then... ugh!!!! Otherwise my new putter and method is yielding much better putting. I did have one "no putt" on #4 from the fringe sank a 14 footer for a par save. Otherwise had a one putt and 6 more two putts. I will continue working on my short game.

Roy Reed's picture

Submitted by Roy Reed (not verified) on

Russty:  Don't feel too bad:  I, too, did the same thing many times.  You can't believe the LARGE number of name-brand clubs I have bought, tried, sold,  traded and gave away., It took me a while to realize there had to be a better way to find a club that actually worked well for me, and that way is to have it built for you by someone that really knows what they are doing. It wasn't until I started participating in this blog that I really learned about proper fittings, etc.  I realize now it is the only way to go if you really want to play better, more consistent golf.  Take care and have a great day.  R2

Amos's picture

Submitted by Amos (not verified) on

DOC:

   well said!
   Now what do you recommend (beyond prayer) for sand that is "hard and packed like concrete"  but also has a high lip on the bunker? Putting is NOT an option - and frequently neither is chipping.

   Keep hittng them STRAIGHT and LONG

   Amos

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Rhig1, Please respond to the call. I have information that Tom Jans, director of marketing for The Surge, is now interested in the old lost 2010 videos , which you said you have saved. I passed your username on through email, so someone may be trying to contact you again in regards to the videos. I am not sure who you were in contact with before by email, but perhaps it would be a good idea for you to contact them again about this endeavor, or contact Tom Jans directly.

Let me be the first to say that I hope this can be worked out some way, and thank you so very much for your willingness to assist in the process.

Rhig1's picture

Submitted by Rhig1 (not verified) on

Terry - Tom Jans just sent me an email on Sat. I told him my problem ,that there were too many blogs to copy very easily. He said he could come down here to Savannah, Ga. and have a devise to copy them more eficiently. He will be calling here tomorrow to discuss this with my wife because I am not a computer expert and she is. Will keep you posted. By the way we have family in Cincinnati and get up there periodically. Maybe we can meet somewhere around Columbus and get a round in. I would like to do the same with Roger as he is just across the river.

Dick H

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Amos,
I think for the same reason that I can roll the ball right down the gutter in bowling. Ha ha!
If they would put the cup at the bottom of the bunker and the pins in the gutter I would be really good at both sports. LOL

Doc Griffin's picture

Submitted by Doc Griffin (not verified) on

Height is not a consideration in proper club length.  How far your hands are off the ground is the measurement that is important.  I would guess though that at your height,  your WTF would be in the 30 to 32 inch range and a standard ladies driver at 44" is too long.  Consider, the average driver length for tour players is 44" to 44.5", I think the standard ladies driver is too long for the average lady.

Your shaft could be cut and I'm sure that there are people there that could do it properly.  The thing to do is to go to the range.  Hit balls with duct tape on the face and keep choking down until you are hitting the majority ( 7 or 8 shots out of 10 ) in the middle of the face.  Mark this spot and have it cut there.  Ask the people that you are considering doing the work if they put weight back in the head when they cut.  If the answer is no, keep looking.  Or.... you could email me and I can tell you how much weight to put back based on how much needs to be cut then you can tell the club maker how much weight to add and look like a pro.

Roy Reed's picture

Submitted by Roy Reed (not verified) on

Doc:  Thanks for the clarification.  After looking at your video that Steve referenced, I realize it is best to pay attention to course conditions, and use the club that will work best for you in those conditions.  Have a great day!  R2 

Robert Thompson's picture

Submitted by Robert Thompson (not verified) on

Hi Roy,

I have three wedges in my set.  A 52* with 8* of bounce, a 56* with 8* of bounce and a 60* with 14* of bounce.  The 52* wedge is mainly for playing off of the fairway and out of the rough, and having the 56* and 60* wedges with different bounces, allows me to play them from differing sand conditions while still being able to use them from outside of the bunkers as well.  In softer sand conditions, I like the 60*/14*, while I use the 56*/8* in harder sand conditions such as after a rain storm.

Hit'em Long and Straight,
Bob

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Hey Robert,
I just went over and played 9 holes at Lil Mole and practiced the things I was working on in the yard today.
The results on the course were that it was probably the best chipping I had ever done off of that grass.
It wasn't as easy as in the yard and the grass still "got me" on one chip where I needed to get up and down for birdie from 20 yards and I left myself a 15 foot putt that I didn't make.
Hard to believe that no matter how hard I try to create the same lie in the yard I can't replicate how tough it is on that course.
I didn't keep score on the course because I chipped extra balls on most of the holes and hit a few extra shots with the driver as well but I'm pretty sure I could have had a really good day.
I also choked down about 1 1/2" on the driver for all of my shots and hit every fairway but one and it was fine and didn't miss by much. Lost no distance whatsoever by choking down that much and my driver is already 44" and I have a WTF of 36".

Lynn42's picture

Submitted by Lynn42 (not verified) on

Mike

Sounds like pretty good shootin to me.  I agree about the heat for sure.  Did not go out all week, temps all over 105 and topped out at 111 combined with high humidity.  I walk and don't mind working up a sweat, but there is a point when you have to use a bit of common sense.

We all do the shoulda, coulda, woulda thing.  Sounds like you are on track to break 80.  Hang in there.

Lynn42

Boogm's picture

Submitted by Boogm (not verified) on

Doc, mine cuts through the dusty dirt Cumberland Lake calls sand very nicely, thank you much!

Robert Thompson's picture

Submitted by Robert Thompson (not verified) on

Hi Robert,
Not yet, I leave for school on 22 August. I'm starting to get a bit antsy to get started. There's tons of stuff to do around the house, I have lots of customers with last minute projects, and tons of golf to play. :0)

Once I know my schedule in September, I'll try to get to Vegas and hook up with You and Robert F.

Hit'em Long and Straight,
Bob

Jimmie Jam's picture

Submitted by Jimmie Jam (not verified) on

Tom
I am not having the volume issues. I can hear the Surge's Youtube just fine on a low volume setting. You might check for another problem or setting.

Regards  Jim

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

It was great fun, even if I couldn't hit an iron to save my life half the time. Oh, well. Surge says 'thin to win,' right? At least it worked really well a few times. If only my putting weren't so lousy right now. Also have to go back and recheck my alignment with the driver, because I hit them well, but pushed most of them.

I also look forward to our next chance to get nine in. I think we'll both be in a little better form.

dgaines's picture

Submitted by dgaines on

Roy,
I have 2 sets of wedges, 52.56.60*
My 52* and 60* wedges all have little bounce. - ranging 3* - 8*. My 56* SW have 12, 14*.
I use the 56* in very fluffy sand and thick rough, otherwise I choose a low bouce wedge depending on distance and trajectory needed.

I don't think there is a 'standard' make up. But this seems to  work for me.

Dan

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Hey Amos,
Prayer is good. You never know unless you ask.;-)

Actually I don't mind that shot unless I am really short sided and the green is running away. I just align left and lay my 60* wide open and take a nice smooth swing along the toe line letting the club slide along on the bounce right into the ball.
It won't work with all wedges though. It has to have a relatively sharp leading edge and very little bounce. (And if you misjudged the "concrete" and it turns out to be not as hard as you thought, that's where the prayer comes in).

A better solution is to stay out of those bunkers.;-)

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Terry,
Glad to hear a sincere effort is being made to recover the 2010 video blogs. There value is beyond words, as are really every daily going back to early 2009.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

One of the guys at Desoto, who is a pretty good player and has won several club championships at Dogwood Hills, never even swings a club before hitting his first tee shot.
He told me one day "I'm not going to forget how to play".
Must be nice but I "forget how to play" almost every day. Ha ha!

Jeff's picture

Submitted by Jeff on

Doc:  Just to clarify, would you mind briefly explaining why you adjust the weight of the club head when you shorten the shaft?

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Hey SGW,
I hate to totally exhaust this thread but I just have to say that after your suggestion I decided to not go play today, at least not yet, and go out in the yard and in the field and practice the sweeping technique.
I started off hitting a few balls at my 10 yard target and it felt OK. I was trying to create similar lies that I have been getting on the course.
When I went to my 20 yard target it wasn't as accurate and something just wasn't feeling quite right, kind of what I've been getting on the course.
One of the balls was just out of reach and I just wanted to quickly hit it to the target so I could move on to another distance and I was aligned right of the target but I kept my club face at the target. I used the same sweeping motion and even though it was in a terrible lie the ball came out perfectly and right at the target. The motion felt better than anything I had done on a chip shot in ages.
Then I went to distances up to 80 yards using the same sweeping technique but aligning right with the club face toward the target.
Unbelievable results. The best I have been since a few years ago when I played every day and many rounds a day. All of those shots were from very bad lies.
When I got finished with all of those distances I wanted to hit some full shots using the normal correct alignment that I always try to use and hit the sand wedge I had been using for the sweep shots at my 115 yard target.
Every one dead at it and only one was the wrong distance and it was the first one and it was too long.
I'm sure I won't be able to resist going over to Lil Mole this afternoon to try what I was doing out in the yard.
It may not be "according to Hoyle" but it sure made that particular shot easy for me, and assured perfect contact almost every time.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Hey Roy,
He already shed quite a bit in this video.

http://www.swingsurgeon.com/Da...

The biggest problem I have with bounce is figuring out what kind of shot to play on Bermuda grass with the grain that can greatly affect how the club reacts as it is entering the grass but just before striking the ball. On tightly mowed fairways this doesn't come into play very often but with the length and thickness they keep the fairways at Lil Mole it comes into play on every chip shot or half wedge shot..

On the other courses that I play I only have to take it into consideration in the rough or even more in the intermediate cut.

Usually I can tell with my practice swing brushing the grass if it's going to be that type of grain that's going to grab the leading edge and suck it right into the ground before ever making good contact with the ball.
If I'm smart enough to change clubs when I realize it I change to a pitching wedge where the bottom edge is a little more rounded and less likely to get affected. It may not produce quite as good a shot as I would have gotten with what should have been the "proper" wedge for the shot, but it's better than coming up short of the green by not making good ball contact. At certain times the grain is so much of a factor that even laying the sand wedge (which has the most bounce) wide open that leading edge will still get sucked under the ball.
Every single regular player at Lil Mole is a "picker" of the ball just for that reason, because that's the only chance we have for consistency, even on full shots. On those little tricky half shots and chip shots where we are not powering through that little bit of grass before the ball it is very, very hard to be consistent at that course.
I would much prefer those shots I have where the lie is hard pan like under a tree or something. On those I know just exactly what the bounce is going to do.

It's an aggravating dilemma on that course. Sometimes we can have a great day off of the tee and still score very poorly because of the less than full approach shots. I don't think the problem is so great that it would outweigh trying to compete by laying up back to full shots in on every hole but it is tempting at times to try it. I'm pretty sure you would have to be a "world class" ball striker to have a chance to win by laying back but it is aggravating just the same.

Funny how even an "easy, short" course can have a little thing like that which levels that so called easiness out. I would say that those days where we get lucky and most of the chip shots are on a down grain lie we all shoot 5 or 6 strokes better than those days where it seems every lie is against the grain.

That is probably why most of us that play there score just as well on the slightly longer and "harder" courses.
Of course on the really long and really tough courses we don't.

Doc Griffin's picture

Submitted by Doc Griffin (not verified) on

Depending on length of shot you could use anything from a pitching wedge to a low bounce sand wedge laid open.  The angle of attack has to be rather steep as well.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Steve, you sound alot like my brother Craig. He's never had a lesson and bombs everything. He never knows what club to use because odds are it's going long. He hits a 9 iron 180 when he's got 150. We are similar build and strength it just is. Heck, any more I am happy to hit a 4 iron or hybrid 180. Craig also never hits any kind of wood even going for the green on a par 5. Driver,iron.
Of course I am both jealous and pproud of him at the ame time. A year a go hit hit a drive 345 and it rolled about 10 yards short of the group on the green. He waved and opologized but you know it was bragging rights. BTW he's 57 years old.

shortgamewizard's picture

Submitted by shortgamewizard (not verified) on

I have a suggestion to try to overcome the Lil Mole bermuda. I use a stiff wrist brush stroke for all chips and pitches up to 50 yards or so. The only exception are sand shots and flops. The technique is to have the shaft perpendicular instead of hands forward. By doing this the bottom of the arc is at the ball. Hope this might work for you.

EdSzal's picture

Submitted by EdSzal (not verified) on

Doc, It seems to me that a "standard" rotational swing is assumed in the design of golf clubs and dictates the lie angle. Does a vertical, surge swing result in the lie angles being a little too flat, and then causing the player to be a little too far from the ball? 

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

One thing is for sure Robert. You are not the first person to chunk a chip and then proceed to three putt.
Mike did it yesterday and if he had made par we would have won the game. And his second putt was no more than 3 feet and almost straight.
Needless to say he wasn't too happy but he took it pretty well and just apologized to the rest of the team.
There was no need to apologize because if the rest of us had played better that putt wouldn't have mattered anyway.

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

The Alien Wedge I mentioned earlier today, along with the Great Escape Wedge, will cut right through the concrete. Just enter an inch or so behind the ball and follow through.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Steve, were you using SGW's stiff wrist idea?
Anyway good playing. I knew you wouldn't resist going to Lil Mole.

Penny's picture

Submitted by Penny on

Hi I have a question Don, I am 5'3" age 64 female and use a standard ladies driver how much shorter should my driver be and can I get my driver cut down or would it be a different shaft put in to keep it all ok. I am from the north of England and don't know of any PPGS club fitters in my area. I play off an 18 handicap and love my golf I have been trying to be more vertical for a while now as I have a weak back. Love your e-mails Penny Holt.

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

I play at so many different courses, with so many different types of maintained and non-maintained green side bunkers that I have only found one club that works for all. It is the one club from my older sets that I continue to keep in play. The Alien Wedge.  For anyone having trouble with green side bunkers, you should give one a try. A very similar copy available through Master Grip is the Great Escape Wedge, well worth the small price of $30.00

http://www.mggolf.com/irons.as...

Doc Griffin's picture

Submitted by Doc Griffin (not verified) on

Nope. Contrary to what you have been told and taught, lie angle is not dictated by swing plane rather the force and release of a weight (club head) on the end of a stick (shaft) which produces toe down or droop.  The amount of force, weight, and relative firmness or softness of the shaft tip is what determines lie angle.

Actually, the modern golf club is designed with a more upright lie angle than years ago.  Reason being that the more upright the club the easier it is to hit left and reduce slicing.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Hey Mike,
Congrats on the eagle, birdie, back to back. That's great!
I too play on courses where I don't have a driving range. We usually spend the first few holes figuring out what we have that day.
I don't know how many strokes that costs us compared to a "proper" warm up session on a range but I'm sure it's several strokes.

Edit:
Hmmm! That may be why I usually play "over my head" and better than normal when I go to a nicer but supposedly harder course, but also has a driving range.

Pages