Trouble Hitting Fairway Woods?

Wed, 10/19/2011 - 19:16 -- Don Trahan

Brian Holland Jones is a 15-handicap player from the UK who is now in his seventies so he's playing really good golf--except for his fairway woods. Here's what he wrote recently:

" My question concerns the use of fairway woods. Frankly, I cannot play any woods from the fairway. They just go low, scurrying along. For these shots, I need to rely on my hybrid 3 or 4, but they don't get me near enough to the green. Then, many longish Par 4s become Par 5s for me. My handicap is 15, I am into my seventies now and live in the UK. Is there any advice, Surge, you can give me? Please help me use my fairway woods and get there in two more often than in three."

Well, Brian, here are several things for you to consider. First, think about which set of tees you are playing from. Many of us still play from the same tees we played from when we were 20-30 years younger. In the U.S., we have a new USGA-PGA sponsored program called "Tee It Forward" which is designed to encourage players to move up to the set of tees where they can consistently land their drives in the same area as a pro could from the pro tees. I've found that many players feel uncomfortable in doing this, partly out of pride and partly because they get "bullied" into playing from the back tees by younger players. I say this is nonsense. We are who we are, and as we get older it is a natural phenomenon to lose strength, suppleness and flexibility. But the one thing we should never lose is our enjoyment of the game. So please consider moving up to a different set of tees if this will give you a decent chance of getting to the green in two on those long Par 4s.

From an equipment perspective, fairway woods (particularly the 3-wood) require considerable Club Head Speed (CHS) to get the ball launched properly. A regular 3-wood will have 15-16 degrees of loft and so you really need the CHS for the ball to roll up the club face and get into the air for any great distance. That's also why long irons are becoming a thing of the past for most amateurs and even many LPGA players. In my opinion, if you don't have the CHS, there is really nothing you can do to improve your results with a regular 3-wood. Instead, I would consider trying a higher-lofted 3-wood, or even better, find a 3-wood hybrid because it will be easier to hit due to its shorter shaft.

Please go to a club fitter who can measure your CHS and launch angle using your existing fairway woods. You'll get objective data on what the right equipment solution is for you and your swing. While you are at it, you may want to have your driver tested too. I know many a senior who has benefited from moving to a high-lofted driver in the 12-14 degree range. Good luck, Brian, in whatever you decide to do.

Keep it vertical!

The Surge

If you can't view the YouTube video above try CLICKING HERE. You must allow popups from this site for the link to work.

Blog Tags: 

Comments

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Roger

I have seen the moderator thing a time or two, but have also found that if I just remove the comments from the first post and make a second identical post it seems to go through to the blog posting find. Weird I know, but it seems to work.

PMG

Jjames's picture

Submitted by Jjames (not verified) on

Surge, I believe that you may have missed the point of the question, how to hit the fairway woods. I have fairly good success in hitting the five wood, but suck when I try hitting the 3 wood, any suggestions?

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

I need to experiment a little with my son's hybrid. I think his is 16* and he hits it the same distance I hit my 5 wood, but I am longer than he is with shorter clubs so I might be able to hit it as far or farther than I hit my 3 wood.

He is usually a good bit longer than I am with a driver but the shorter the club the more I am longer than he is.

I think that's typical in a rotational vs. vertical swing.

shortgamewizard's picture

Submitted by shortgamewizard (not verified) on

I have a Sonartec 13 fairway metal that you can have if you want. Let me know and I have a number of shafts that can be put in it.

methodicalbear's picture

Submitted by methodicalbear (not verified) on

Disqus generic email templateThe best club you have at your disposal is your own body :that's what you should be working on ,not only in strength building ,which is useless for golf ,but on flexibility and "explosive " speed .Several fitness books should be perused ,I would mention "Fix your body ,fix your swing "by Joey DIOVISALVI , "Thirty exercises for better golf " by Dr Frank JOBE (This book is 30 years old and is still fully valid ) .As for the comment on using the three wood (loft 15°) full length ,It is useful off the tee on long par 3 's ,but off thedeck I find it easier to grip down .I definitely believe ,at least this iworks for me ! ) that placing the ball more towars the center of the stance helps because as age comes ,we have difficulties moving our weight fast enough on the front foot Raymond Chastel
chastel.raymond@wanadoo.fr
----- Original Message -----
From: Disqus
To: chastel.raymond@wanadoo.fr
Sent: Thursday, October 20, 2011 8:16 PM
Subject: [?? Probable Spam] [swingsurgeon] Re: Trouble Hitting Fairway Woods? - The Surge's Daily Blog

Doc Griffin wrote, in response to methodicalbear:

Really? As a teaching professional as well as a master fitter, I take exception to your information and suggestions. Where you put the ball in your stance is relative to your club length and release point. It has nothing to do with speed or age.
Also, my heartiest congratulations on having the club head speed of 95mph. This is awesome at an age of 77. In fact, it's miraculous. At that club head speed, you should have no problem playing a 3 wood at all anyway.
Link to comment

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Hey Phil, (or anyone else)
I have often heard people make the statement you made about cavity backs  vs. blades.

I have never owned any blades and have only hit them a few times when I was hitting another person's club.

I truly didn't see any difference  in the ability to work the ball with either one. The cavity backs may be more forgiving on off center hits but I don't see how that relates to working the ball. I (hopefully) will hit the ball dead center with either type of club whether I am working the ball or not. So the "forgiveness" part is a moot point as far as working the ball.

Maybe you guys can tell me why I'm wrong.;-)

Amos's picture

Submitted by Amos (not verified) on

Robert Meade:

    I concur with you sir!  In true "different Amos" fashion -- I can still hit the 3W well to very well -- for the first 10 or 11 holes.  Then fatigue sets in, the Swing Speed goes down and the 3W becomes usesless :<((

   Currently the 3W is out of the bag in favor of a 3H and 4th wedge which I find to more useful.

    Keep hittting them STRAIGHT and LONG

    Amos

Doc Griffin's picture

Submitted by Doc Griffin (not verified) on

Really?  As a teaching professional as well as a master fitter, I take exception to your information and suggestions.  Where you put the ball in your stance is relative to your club length and release point.  It has nothing to do with speed or age.

Also, my heartiest congratulations on having the club head speed of 95mph.  This is awesome at an age of 77.  In fact, it's miraculous.  At that club head speed, you should have no problem playing a 3 wood at all anyway.

Dr. G's picture

Submitted by Dr. G (not verified) on

Surge's comments seem on-target if the player is making a swing that contacts the ball squarely on the sweet spot.  A variation on the fairway wood problem that I have is inconsistency in height of the swing - so that the ball is either hit too high and does not get a good launch, or is hit too low so that the club head digs into the turf and imparts little energy to the ball.  When I get the height just right, the ball gets good loft and distance.  The question is how can I cure the inconsistent height of the swing.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

DJ tees off at 7:50am tomorrow. Stay tuned Surgites. Go Deej!

Jack Hill's picture

Submitted by Jack Hill (not verified) on

Hi Roger, my comment re "not showing much respect for us 'over 75s" was not meant for you at all.
It was meant jokingly for Doc who took exception to Methodicalbear´s (77 years young) information and suggestions on ball position and club head speed.  In fact it was what I would call a friendly defence of the +75 Club, many of whose members are Surge´s followers.  Doc´s knowledge of this great game deserves my full respect, so I would never want to offend him at all
If I hurt anyone´s feelings I hereby apologise.

I have found nothing nicer on the web than our group of Surgites who "meet" every day to listen to Surge and then comment on our golfing problems and experiences. It is something I look forward to every afternoon with much anticipation.
Quite frankly my scores have greatly improved since putting into practice the PPGS vertical swing (I have the manual and videos) plus the knowledge and the tips which appear on this blog, be they from Surge or from Surgites.

PMG and good luck !!

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Jack,

 Me too. I carry no fairway woods. I have 3-hybrids, 16* 20* and 26* properly fit by a certified PPGS fitter. I hit the 16* hybrid better and farther than any 3-wood I have ever had or tried.

 As Surge mentioned in this video. The best advice for seniors and fairway woods is to get rid of them. I say, get a shovel and bury them deep in the back yard, then bury the shovel. In other words just get them out of the bag so you won't be tempted to use them. I actually sold all of my old ones.

 Then, find a certified club fitter and be properly fit for Hybrids. All I can say is it worked for me. In addition, my higher lofted driver also works better than my old name brand 10.5* driver.

Good Luck to all

PMG

shortgamewizard's picture

Submitted by shortgamewizard (not verified) on

If there is a fitter around I would check the specs on the 5W and see if the 3W matches. Off the shelf clubs with the same shaft and flex can spec all over the place. That is why Doc is in business. Most of the big companies don't have really good quality control, nor do they care as much for the customer as they do sales volume.

methodicalbear's picture

Submitted by methodicalbear (not verified) on

Disqus generic email templateThe best club you have at your disposal is your own body :that's what you should be working on ,not only in strength building ,which is useless for golf ,but on flexibility and "explosive " speed .Several fitness books should be perused ,I would mention "Fix your body ,fix your swing "by Joey DIOVISALVI , "Thirty exercises for better golf " by Dr Frank JOBE (This book is 30 years old and is still fully valid ) .As for the comment on using the three wood (loft 15°) full length ,It is useful off the tee on long par 3 's ,but off thedeck I find it easier to grip down .I definitely believe ,at least this iworks for me ! ) that placing the ball more towars the center of the stance helps because as age comes ,we have difficulties moving our weight fast enough on the front foot Raymond Chastel
chastel.raymond@wanadoo.fr
----- Original Message -----
From: Disqus
To: chastel.raymond@wanadoo.fr
Sent: Thursday, October 20, 2011 8:16 PM
Subject: [?? Probable Spam] [swingsurgeon] Re: Trouble Hitting Fairway Woods? - The Surge's Daily Blog

Doc Griffin wrote, in response to methodicalbear:

Really? As a teaching professional as well as a master fitter, I take exception to your information and suggestions. Where you put the ball in your stance is relative to your club length and release point. It has nothing to do with speed or age.
Also, my heartiest congratulations on having the club head speed of 95mph. This is awesome at an age of 77. In fact, it's miraculous. At that club head speed, you should have no problem playing a 3 wood at all anyway.
Link to comment

Kelly's picture

Submitted by Kelly on

I'm actually going in the opposite direction to many of you. I took my 3 iron, 3-wood and 5-wood out of my bag about three years ago and replaced them with 16 and 19 degree hybrids and an extra wedge. But earlier this year I decided that I wasn't enjoying my hybrids and that I didn't hit them with the kind of accuracy I expected. So, back came my 3I, 3W, and 5W, and I I don't think I'll be changing back any time soon. I found the "secret." :)

I think that one of the biggest faults people have when hitting long fairway irons/woods is that they try to "crush" the ball and end up swinging too hard. Some time ago I read about an experiment someone did (it may have been Tom Wishon, but I don't know for sure) where they had a number of people swing a 5-iron and a 3-iron and they gauged both the swing and the result. The swing speed with the 3-iron was considerably faster for almost all of the testers, and the ball-striking with the 3I was much more inconsistent. The thing is, the two clubs were identical -- they had the exact same loft, shaft length, flex, weight, etc. The only thing that had been changed was the number on the bottom of the club.

Hitting the club consistently on the sweet spot with a slower, smoother swing will result in more length (and accuracy) than a fast swing speed that misses the centre of the club. So, the "secret" I found to hitting the longer fairway clubs consistently clean was a smooth, relaxed TEMPO, avoiding the temptation to "crush it" at all costs. I even play tricks on myself picking a spot well back from my intended landing area and telling myself that I only want to hit it there. I will find myself saying to myself (even into my backswing) things like "Remember, you don't have to advance this ball very far to be in good shape. Just hit it to the 150." Usually the results are much better. I can't believe the number of really long 3W and 5W shots I hit this year (and all I wanted to was hit it to the 150 -- go figure :)). 

Jack Hill's picture

Submitted by Jack Hill (not verified) on

Amos, it´s comforting to know that someone else also gets tired after the first dozen holes and that as a result Swing Speed is reduced.
My game does suffer as a result and here is where the hybrids come in very handy !!

Jack Hill's picture

Submitted by Jack Hill (not verified) on

I think that Surge is saying that if we oldies (I´m 76) were to tee off from a "senior teeing ground", which may be close to or next to the ladies tee, we would be landing our drives closer to the hole and avoid what Brian Holland Jones said that his long Par 4s become Par 5s for him.
Thus we will get more enjoyment out of our game since par 4s can be played as par 4s.
I agree with Surge that the best long distance fairway club is a 3-hybrid which in my case has given me much satisfaction in distance and accuracy.

Dan's picture

Submitted by Dan on

At what age should you be able to play from senior tees? I play 3 days a week in a group of older guys. They want you to be 70 to play from senior tees. I am 64 with a lumbar disk problem, neuropathy in both legs, controlled hypertension and an enlarged aorta. I feel great (except for persistant back pain) and my best drives are @ 220-230. Have found it harder to get pars and birdies lately and bogeys only get one point. Tell them top let me play from the red tees unless you think I am still too young. Thanks, Dan

MikefromKy Go Bama. Go Irish's picture

Submitted by MikefromKy Go B... (not verified) on

I am thinking of having a new 3w 16* built if I can find a smaller head than the launcher 3wd I have its not the easiest to hit out of the fairways with the bigger head but is really easy off the tee.  

Dragonhead's picture

Submitted by Dragonhead (not verified) on

At the end of yesterdays practice round I was smoking the 5W, getting accuracy and distance. It has a 22deg loft. Just checked my 3W[which I hit very well also], it has a 16deg loft.The Drv has an 11deg loft and I hit it much better than the r7Quad with it's 10.5deg loft. This seems to confirm the fact that 0.5of a degree, can indeed make a big difference.
Loaded and ready to have another round today heh heh heh. May only play a few holes. See how it goes.PMGAS

MikefromKy Go Bama. Go Irish's picture

Submitted by MikefromKy Go B... (not verified) on

shortgamewizard
That's  the same 17 that I have and I love it off the tee or the fairway I have been sitting here thinking that does it really make any sense to take the 17 out and put a 16 in and the answer is no.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Wow! Is Disqus going wild or did you post the same comment many times?

You did say one thing that caught my interest when you said the the three wood full length comes in handy off of the tee on long par threes.

For me the optimum length for any club, whether off of the tee or off of the ground, is the same. When I hit my three wood the ball really doesn't know whether it is sitting on a tee or on the ground.

 I can see where people that really don't have sufficient swing speed to properly get a three wood in the air might use an ascending blow off of the tee that isn't possible off of a tight lie, but even that doesn't require a longer club.

That shouldn't be the case for you with your swing speed. Looks like you could make the same swing with the same club, whether it is on a tee or not.

You must be playing some awfully long golf courses if you are needing to hit three woods off of the tee on par threes with your swing speed. We don't have many par threes around here that are over 225 yards.

The funny thing is that the cheapest (and crappiest) course around here does have the longest par 3 at 240 yards. Since it also has a big oak tree slightly right of the middle of the fairway it forces either a big hook or slight slice or to use a club lofted enough to go over it, like a 4 iron, which will come up short unless it it really hammered.
 Then to top it all off the entire green slopes so severely from left to right that any ball on the green will roll off. And then the greens on that course are all rougher than a gravel road. We joke that it is the hardest par 3 in the world. Ha ha.

MikefromKy Go Bama. Go Irish's picture

Submitted by MikefromKy Go B... (not verified) on

The tour I play on offered to have a senior division this year but all the seniors said no to it. They said they would rather play the division that there handicap put them in.Which the seniors we have are all low handicappers anyway.

The skins game that I used to play in we had a retired jockey that played with us he was in his 60's we all played the white tees @ 5800 I never saw him shoot over 75 he had a great short game but he would not play when it was wet out because of loss of roll on his tee shot. I never saw him out of the fairway off the tee either. 

louis's picture

Submitted by louis on

Surge, I used to play in UK many years ago before moving to Australia where golf was set up similarly & I don't think things will have changed.  In Oz we have 3 basic tee positions - members men & members women, (which are used when we play comp, usually 3 days a week), then social players which we can use when we're just out for a social hit.  On occasion on medal days or if a major comp is held at a course, blue or black tee positions are added a few yards further back, so I don't think the situation is quite the same as in USA from what you described it.  We certainly don't have an option of playing off forward tees in our comp rounds.

Re the issue of fairway woods, I found that I hit my 5 wood almost as far as my 3 when fairways are lush, but in summer over here (N Queensland), the fairways brown off in the heat, so the 3 wood gains distance because of the run you get & in fact I prefer to hit my 2 iron under those conditions for the same reason.

dgaines's picture

Submitted by dgaines on

If you are out having a non-competitive game of golf, play the tees that you want.

If you are in a league, you would need to follow the league rules.

Doc Griffin's picture

Submitted by Doc Griffin (not verified) on

You do realize that as soon as the ball hits the ground that it's slowing down.  The ball will fly further than it will roll.  Quit trying to hit clubs that don't fit you any more and get the correct ones that do.

shortgamewizard's picture

Submitted by shortgamewizard (not verified) on

For all of you who are hitting the fairway wood good off the tee and not the fairway try playing the ball farther back in your stance. This will help put a bit more spin on the ball which will help it stay in the air longer. I have seen a lot of players try to help the ball into the air which does the opposite. If this doesn't help then go with Surge's suggestion on playing higher loft woods. Maybe a 17 degree for the 3 wood.

Roy Reed's picture

Submitted by Roy Reed (not verified) on

Dr. G:  The Surge did a video blog a while back about the importance of setting and maintaining your spine angle thru impact.  If you change your spine angle during the BUS and the FUS, your shots will be as you describe - tops, thins and chunks, along with a host of other swing-related problems.  Surge also talked about "secondary spine-angle tilt" and how that plays into the swing.  Go to the top right of this blog, under "Search Posts" and type in what you arre looking for (spine-angle tilt and secondary tilt).  You should be able to find some detailed help and more information. Hit 'em straight!  R2 

Doc Griffin's picture

Submitted by Doc Griffin (not verified) on

Exactimundo

My thoughts exactly.  At that club head speed there shouldn't be any trouble getting the ball airborne and the length shouldn't be a problem either.  Also, the mention of getting the weight over to the front font shouldn't be an issue as well or I just don't see 95mph club head speed being a reality.  So, I'm just going to have to let it go as it just doesn't seem to all add up from a logical and physics standpoint.

Fred juliano's picture

Submitted by Fred juliano (not verified) on

Ted,
You miss the point. It wasn't the loft that is a problem most of the time that players have with their fairway woods, it's the fear of hitting it with the foreward edge and taking a divot and/or too much turf. Look closely at anyone having trouble with their fairway woods on bent grass fairways and other tight lies, and you will find that most of the time, they're hitting along the top portion of the ball.  It takes a lot of practice and to sweep the turf exactly without taking a divot which is required for a good hit using the fairway woods.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

I have used the cavity backs since the Ping Eye 2 days. In fact I still have my Dads. But I switched to smaller blades a few months ago and love 'em. I have the Vega VM02'S forged in Japan.
http://www.premiumgolf.co.uk/V...
They look and feel great. Surge compares using the often larger cavity backs to using a frying pan to hit the ball with. The idea that the sweet spot is larger on the modern cavity back is bogus. The sweet spot is actually the size of a pea. In any case, what ever you feel you hit the best will be best for you in my opinion whether cavity, blade or a composite. If you get fitted clubs, hopefully you'll have a fitter that will not only have you try the clubs inside on monitors but outside at a range or on a course in the real world invironment. I was lucky that way. When i tried the blades i just felt good about the feel and the results. I know many will say it doesn't matter and that's fine too. that's why we have so many options.
Without getting into it too deeply, steel or graphite has nothing to do with flex. Each can have a complete aray of soft to firm. I have graphite in my irons btw. Matrix.

MikefromKy Go Bama. Go Irish's picture

Submitted by MikefromKy Go B... (not verified) on

I assume that DISQUS is working on there system again there was about 15 minutes that I could not get the blogs to load and there site would not load properly this has happen to me a couple of time this week. has any else seen this.

I also noticed that they are adding another feature that will not allow a questionable post to be posted until a moderator approves it.

Jack Hill's picture

Submitted by Jack Hill (not verified) on

Doc,
I have two hybrids : a 19° Baffler Cobra and a 23°  4-year-old steel shaft, and my approximate distances for each are as follows, when hitting solid shots, which is not always the case !!  :

19° full club length : 170 yards
19° shorter club length : 155 yards
23° full club length : 140 yards
23° shorter club length : 125 yards.

I have difficulty in hitting fairway woods 3 and 5 which I´m about to throw out of my bag,  and irons below 7.  Therefore on the fairway I am now relying almost entirely on my hybrids until I´m within 120 yards from the hole.  From this distance I start to use my irons.

I have read umpteen times that one should have clubs which are fitted to one´s abilities, body build, etc. but so far have not got down to doing this.  This will be my New Year´s Resolution for 2012 when I collect my end-of-year bonus.

I wish to thank Surge and yourself for all your expert help on this blog, very much appreciated.

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

It is almost comical, that you answered your own question with your last sentence.
" (Yes, I know, I'm also increaing the loft.)"

 If you have to be so precise with the lower lofted club, even to the point of actually increasing the loft with a modified swing. Why not just get and use a higher lofted club and avoid all of the manipulations. Even better, be properly fit for hybrids.

 Surge gave excellent advice, that it seems so many just want to argue against because it doesn't fit in with their ideas.  Sometimes we are our own worst enemies when we fail to accept the advice of others. We just do not want to believe, that we can no longer hit our old clubs the way we used to a few years ago. The truth is often an ugly beast, but there comes a time when we have to face it.

Good luck.

PMG

MikefromKy Go Bama. Go Irish's picture

Submitted by MikefromKy Go B... (not verified) on

I hope DJ finishes on a good note and  or Wins. This should be a good tournament to watch with Simpson and Donald fighting it out for the money list champion.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

3 wood or 5 wood better for you?  Found a good answer from Doc. Be ready to park your ego by the side of the fairway.
http://tmgolf.sports.officeliv...

Another good one on the same subject:
http://www.swingsurgeon.com/Ho...

Hope this helps some with the challenge of why they are challenged to get thier 3 woods to work well for them any more. Enjoy and thanks Doc :)

methodicalbear's picture

Submitted by methodicalbear (not verified) on

Disqus generic email templateIn response to Doc Griffin and Steve SMITH :Though I don't agree with your comment , I shall honestly try again to hit the three wood flush from the ground with the full length of the shaft and see if you are right and Tom WATSON wrong .I shall let you know the outcome .Regarding another comment by DON TRAHAN ,I don't agree neither with the recommendation to throw the Long irons out of the bag :I have an old 1 Iron PING perimeter weighted which works beautifully of the tee on long par Three's Raymond Chastel
chastel.raymond@wanadoo.fr

methodicalbear's picture

Submitted by methodicalbear (not verified) on

  The tip regarding how to hit a 3 wood flush when you put on age(Ball in the middle of the stane ,shorten your grip,open your stance somewhat ) is from TOM WATSON himself (See his book "THE TIMELESS SWING  " )Tom has proven in the recent BRITISH OPEN that he remains competitive despite his age .
There nothing miraculous in having a clubhead speed of 95 MPH and 250 Yards off the tee at age 77 if you practice daily 2 /3 hours stretching , strengthening  and cardio trainng exercises .Anbody fit enough can achieve it ,provided he has the will to do so . 
The above figures are not fake and  result from measures with the SWING SPEED RADAR and pacing the distances on the fairway.

Fred juliano's picture

Submitted by Fred juliano (not verified) on

This brings up a subject that has been annoying me no end.  The USGA and other PGA pros like to pontificate about how we should use the tees up forward if we are not long hitters. All well and good.  But I would like to ask these "know it alls" when was the last time they went to the trouble of putting a men's handicape rating and slope on the forward tees. The USGA preaches about their not being a Mens' tee versus a Women's tee. but I have yet to find a club that has both men and women's ratings and slope on the most foreward tees and very few courses that have both mens' and women's ratings on the white tees. On one particular outing, the club Pro dutifully announced "All men on the white tees and all women on the red tees". I asked (I'm 80 years old and my partner 85) what about us seniors? He reiterated his ruling. I then asked him "What if Tiger Woods and Micelle Wee were in this outing? Would we seniors have to play from the white tees against T. Woods, whereas  M. Wee would be able to play from the red tees?" He shrugged his shoulders, smiled and walked back into the clubhouse without answering.

In addition, I also think the Surge gave a non-responsive answer to the question. I find that I have to be very careful and be sure I hit the ball with the club just slightly brushing the ground on tight fairways which of course, can sometimes be easier said than done, especially when distance is so important for the 2nd stroke in long par 4s. I found that by tipping the club ever so slightly to be sure the club would hit the ground along the tail end of the club rather than the face end, I am able to hit the ball much more cosistently on tight fairways. Doing so, allows me to swing with a more relaxed swing knowing I won't be digging the face into the turf if I don't hit it just right. (Yes, I know, I'm also increaing the loft.)

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Neil,

Up until this year, I also played Cobra, 3,5,7, and 9, woods. I had tried several off the rack Hybrids and could not hit any of them as well as the fairway woods. When my PPGS Fitter made the first two hybrids for me, a 26* and a 20*, I couldn't believe how more consistent they were than my woods. I requested he make an additional 16* for those long par 4, second shots and was amazed to find I could hit it just as well as the 26* one. All three clubs swing the same regardless of the different lofts and lengths. It was then a pleasure to sell my Cobras to one of my golfing buddies.

The difference is in having the hybrids made by a professional fitter to fit your swing, and not just an off the rack hybrid.

PMG

MikefromKy Go Bama. Go Irish's picture

Submitted by MikefromKy Go B... (not verified) on

Jack

All is good my friend. No need to apologize for anything.

Roger
 

Jack Hill's picture

Submitted by Jack Hill (not verified) on

TM, very good advice to get rid of fairway woods.  Today I was tempted and took my 3 and 5 woods to the course and was I sorry that I used them, since I found that my BUS was entering the SBG with these clubs.  I then switched over to my 18° and 24° hybrids and everything changed very much for the better.

I will follow your excellent advice to get them out of my bag (tonight !!) but I won´t bury them deep in the back garden ('yard' in the USA) and instead will resell them at the pro shop and hope to get a good price since all golf clubs are imported here in Argentina.

PMG and PLHR with nose pointing at the ball !!

Dragonhead's picture

Submitted by Dragonhead (not verified) on

Hi Jack, I only have a 24deg Rescue club with a short shaft, which could be called a hybrid. Only have it because I won it in a competition in the UK Golf mag Today's Golfer.Quite a surprise,but a welcome one. Love it. Not using it much at the moment as my other clubs have started earning their keep.Yesterday terrible,but today much better. Overswinging with the F/W Woods is the main cause. Today much better. Slower BUS and through the ball with the wee bump and the distance almost doubles.Accuracy is one of the big plusses.
My wife commented on something today and I [being a sensible chap listened heh heh heh] heeded what she said. Today my approach shots were very accurate. The SW is perorming like it was Phil Mickelson swinging the club. All shots to the green were less than 3/4s of the length of my putter from the hole with my SW.Boy does that give you confidence. On one hole the 5W left me a short iron to the green on a long par 5 into the wind. Used a club not used for a while, 7iron and nailed the green. Even had my driver out, One clipped tree overhanging branches and ended up shorter than normal. It was however well struck. The only other one went extremely well and my approach with a 5W was only a yard short of the green, dead on line with the pin.So all in all a more satisfying day today. Only downside. After the round my wife beat me 1up after a 9hole putting competition using my original Ping Pal Putter boohoo. Never mind, her putting was sublime and a well deserved win.
Thanks for the ABs support for the game against Sarkozy's lot on Sunday.PS his wife has just  given birth to a daughter. That'll teach him hahaha. Hit em long and straight mi amigo.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Nobody is saying that you can hit your three wood off of the ground by holding it at it's full length as well as you do choking down. (In fact the opposite).

I'm not even disagreeing with Tom Watson. The reason we would move the ball back in our stance after choking down is that it becomes, in effect, a shorter club and we know that the clubs move progressively forward in the stance as they get longer. So a shorter club would of course be farther back.

All I am saying is that if you are having to choke down the club is probably too long to begin with. And that if it was the proper length to hit well off of the ground it would also be perfectly fine off of the tee.

What you are doing (and I certainly don't have a problem with it) is using your three wood as two different clubs. One choked down for fairway shots, and one full length for tee shots. With a rotational swing that would equate to more distance with the full length but more control with the choked down version.
I have found that doesn't necessarily hold true for a vertical swing and I can swing my arms so much faster with the shorter shaft that it cancels out the length of the longer shaft and is a wash in club head speed.

Surge and Doc recommend to take the long irons out of the bag when either you can no longer hit them very well or if you can hit a hybrid better than you can hit the long irons.

Most people have trouble hitting long irons and those people would be foolish to not explore better options. I hit my long irons very well but would still be open to hybrids if I found an advantage to them. I ain't crazy. I'll hit anything that helps my game. It just so happens that all of the hybrids I've hit so far aren't any better than my long irons.

Neither Don nor Doc nor anyone else is twisting your arm to get you (or me) to take our long irons out of the bag. They are just giving common sense advice that if we can't hit a long iron very well there are other options.
To disagree with that common sense advice just makes you sound as if you are just looking for something to disagree with.
Wouldn't you give the same advice to someone that was struggling to hit a long iron?

Pages